Menu Close

Celtic v Hibernian: Etims Expert Analysis

Uralius looks ahead to what promises to be a cracker, in a mature and thoughtful way, suggesting he’ll never get a job with Sky Tv, the BBC or the Daily Record

 

So I’ve sent this to Ralph in the hope he posts it.
I’ve decided to take a partially informed and unapologetic loudmouth approach to my writing. Meaning most of my writing will be about my opinions based on very little evidence. If I do present evidence please don’t bother double checking it as it’s highly likely I made that evidence up too. Unless of course it’s from Celtic by numbers (I love that site) in which case it’s true!
So where are we right now?
We have just come off of an international break we all know what has been going on and most of it’s a disgrace, but that has been covered and I am only here to pick a starting 11 against Hibs. I’ve seen a couple of OPINIONS on websites like thisisfutbol.com, but honestly I doubt any of them are right. I also doubt any of those writing the multitude of expected 11s out there even watch Celtic week in and week out, so guess what? I don’t give a crap about their opinions, they’re wrong!
I’m hoping the 3 at the back or 5 at the back experiment is well and truly OVER! It didn’t work, we don’t have enough center backs and although it gives you a chance to play 1 more midfielder than 4 at the back does you are playing, at the very least 1 of those midfielders out of position. Recently it has been James Forrest who has “taken one for the team,” but in all honesty the entire team has suffered.
So what do we think Hibs are going to do?
They have lined up with a flat back 4 for all games this season except in the League Cup Quarter final against Aberdeen where they played a back 3. I think it’s highly likely they are going to line up with a flat back 4. From what I’ve seen (and it’s no much) it looks like they will be protected by a very experienced defensive midfielder in Mark Milligan and we can expect them to defend very well, but experience tells us that we are likely to be gifted at least 1 chance due to a defensive error… if you know what I mean.
Offensively they are likely to play very direct; 4 or 5 quick passes and you can find yourself carved open. The players from the left tend to cut-in more while the players on the right seem to prefer diagonal balls and balls over the top into the right and center channels although these players are mostly right footed they seem very good at bulging the net just inside the left-hand post a la James Forrest.
So a 4-1-4-1 sitting deep, keeping their shape and counter-attacking in numbers.
Something we have to consider is that Scott Brown has been out injured. In days gone by we would all be greetin that the team cannae function without him, that there is no drive without him and it certainly was true, but we saw a team carve open St. Johnstone time and time again without Broony, so there will be no rushing him back. We have a game against a team worth 248m pound coming up and that’s the game we need him for.
Why change the back 4 of Lustig, Boyata, Benkovic and Tierney? Oh yeah because that seems to be what we do these days. So against my better judgement I am predicting that Simunovic starts with Benkovic coming on as a substitute, oh gawd I really hope not….. Please, please, please start Benkovic, no disrespect to Simunovic, I just don’t think he’s ready for a start this weekend although I can’t wait to see him take the field against Dundee.
Oh and before any of you complain about Lustig being in my team know this, he is one of the best in our team at providing the providers (secondary assists and something) and there is evidence (guess where)!
So after a quick look at a couple of recent stories from Celtic by numbers (did I mention I love that site?) the rest of the team practically picks itself. With the top partnerships that produce all the chances coming from Forrest/Rogic, Ntcham/Sinclair, Forrest/McGregor, Ntcham/Tierney, Griffiths/McGregor and Ntcham/McGregor. We’ll have McGregor Right Central Midfield, Ntcham Left Central Midfield, Rogic in the hole, with Griff upfront and the 2 wide men exactly where you’d expect.
Oh no we won’t! We have a record breaking striker that MUST play! Oh really?
Listen he is a good player, but needs more time to settle, put him on the bench for this one and bring him on in a wide target man role when we are 2.5 goals up.
Due to Sinclair cutting in a lot (a lot? You mean all the time) our width has to be provided by Tierney in the final 3rd, Ntcham will have to be aware of this and cover if Hibs try and counter attack down our left, their right… you know with those diagonal balls etc.

With Lustig and McGregor playing behind Forrest who can either go for the byline or cut in, more awareness will be required with McGregor covering when Jamesie cuts in and Lustig covering the rest of the time. I believe our opening goal will likely come from overloading Mark Milligan in the middle with Griff, Sinclair and Rogic before farming the ball out only for it to come swiftly back into the middle while the defense is in disarray.
What do you think? Discuss below (not because there are a ton of adverts between this work of opinionated drivel and the comments section, but because some people on here actually care what you think). If you liked this article please subscribe to email notifications and type PISH! In the comments section.

 

0 0 votes
Article Rating
27 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
5 years ago

Good article, and have to agree mostly with team selection, but I’d like tae see Morgan get the nod ahead of Sinclair, he’s to predictable and not direct enough when running at defender’s, making it easier tae isolate him out of a game, Morgan has more natural skill and is hungry, and can hopefully unlock a stubborn defence with some slick through ball’s for Griffiths….COYBIG

Rebus67
5 years ago

Good article! Lots of talking points.

I agree that Hibs will start with a back 4 and your 4-1-4-1 is a good bet.

It is more difficult to suss what we will do. Brown should be rested but probably won’t. He likes to play against Hibs. You are correct Benkovic should start and I think he will. Simo on the bench. Rogic will play depending on how fit he is after his travels, and, to BR, McGregor is a must. Also, Edouard will start because a) BR wanted him, and b) we paid big bucks for him. He does not need time to settle…he was here all of last season. He needs to be more confident, which appears to be happening.

If we play to the byeline and follow with accurate crosses, and if we play the ball into the channels for players to run onto, we shall win easily. However, if we try to short pass through their middle, it is anybody’s guess.

Great game to have after the break…..heck, any game would be grest!

Rebus

Uralius
5 years ago
Reply to  Rebus67

Fair play Rebus and thanks for the feedback. I think Dembele departing how he did unsettled all the players, but probably impacted Edouard the most. I probably should’ve said something like, “who is still getting used to a club without Moussa Dembele.”
You correctly identified what I was on the fence about, that is what I wouldn’t do that I’m sure BR will.

jimmybee
5 years ago

Scott Sinclair seems to be getting it in the neck but for me he is a goalscorer. He wouldn’t be out my team. St Johnstone were carved open all our players were forward thinking. No side or back passes we got the ball and moved it quickly. Simple eh?.
I think the next 2 domestic games are more important than the Europa league. So my full attention would be on those.
Gordon
Lustig Benkovic Boyata Tierney
Forrest Ntcham McGregor
Griff Edouard Sinclair.
Let the goals flow.
Looking forward to the game.
HH

BJF
5 years ago

Like the article maybe keep Tierney keep him for the two Hearts and the Leipzig games give Izzy a run. Similarly I would keep Broonie for those games otherwise much as you suggest, just the faintest hint of Sinky going in the outside once or twice in his last run out so I would play him, maybe Mulumbu too.

Wufti67
5 years ago

Just tell wee Jamesy to hit the by line instead of cutting inside all the time

Monti
5 years ago
Reply to  Wufti67

If Forrest went outside EVERY time, the full back will just show him outside every time, then get a tackle in, did you play at all?

Rebus67
5 years ago

Jimmy,

I think Sinclair is not the player he was in his first season for whatever reason. He is not a player that can handle the physical side of the game. In the first season he had the confidence to take on players and use his speed to go past them. His shooting was accurate. Now, because defenders show physicality, he has lost confidence in taking them on. They know this. He is easily pushed off the ball, or blocked from getting to the ball. Whether he can overcome this, I do not know. However, he still has a role to play by coming off the bench in the second half when defenders have tired. Pity, because he was the complete forward in the first season.

Rebus

Rebus67
5 years ago

P S

He has two goals in six starts and nine sub appearances. Not a great output.

Rebus

Devoy45
5 years ago

All this is good, really sound. I think Sinclair must be in there. He can win free kicks which Griff can convert. We need reminded that our best flowing football this season was without Broonie in the team. Why?
McGinn was the Hibee who troubled us most so they need to trouble us without him—a big ask.
To the bhoys 3-1. I’m no feart.

charlie
5 years ago

good article ime startin tae believe yoor no donnchadh on account ae that being to clever fur him he he

charlie
5 years ago
Reply to  charlie

^sodgers groupie

jimmybee
5 years ago

I think being left out the team was the biggest factor Rebus. If he had started against AEK we might have been in a different european competition. But its all about opinions m8.
I’m sure Brendan will get it right tomorrow and whoever he picks will get my full support.
Looking forward to paradise on a Saturday afternoon HH.

Rebus67
5 years ago
Reply to  jimmybee

Jimmy,

You are correct…it is only opinions. Who ever is playing will have my full support.

Rebus

Iancelt67
5 years ago
Reply to  jimmybee

Yeah I remember that night jimmy

5 years ago

Griff is ill and Rogic is rested, otherwise the article is pish.

Monti
5 years ago

PISH

Uralius
5 years ago
Reply to  Monti

Glad you liked it Monti. Beware playing a striker up there all alone with no support.

Monti
5 years ago

Only kidding Uralius,
My tactics would be 4-2-3-1

Gordon

Lustig
Boyata
Benkovic
Tierney

Brown
Ntcham

Forrest
Rogic
McGregor

Edouard

Uralius
5 years ago

It’ll appear the morra after the game, you’ll be screaming I told you so! While we are all sagging you off.

Uralius
5 years ago
Reply to  Uralius

*slaggin’

PaddyBhoy
5 years ago

Morgan got MOM against England. I couldn’t see it, myself, but he needs a run in the team. So, Sinclair on the bench, and Morgan in for him.

Monti
5 years ago

Alternatively we could go 4-1-4-1

Gordon

Lustig
Boyata
Benkovic
Tierney

Brown

Forrest
Ntcham
Rogic
Sinclair

Edouard

Iancelt67
5 years ago

PISH

Uralius
5 years ago

I haven’t liked 3 at the back since it stopped working for MON. It will take a miracle of epic proportions for me to believe we should be using it.

OBzcelt
5 years ago

I think with news about Griffiths injury I see Gordon- Back four Lustig, Benkovic, Boyata, Tierney, —I wold like to see Mulumbu and McGregor sitting if Brown isn’t ready as Ntcham needs a break. Forrest, Rogic (Big Game player)Sinclair–Eddy

Uralius
5 years ago

Wish they hadn’t risked Broony.

Follow us on Twitter @ETimsNet

Discover more from eTims

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading